Italian restaurants

Central Pizza - ON L2A 3S5

4.2 228 reviews 3:00 AM - 9:00 PM 161 Central Ave, Fort Erie, ON L2A 3S5, Canada

Discover this place

Central Pizza is an Italian restaurant located on Central Avenue in Fort Erie, Ontario. It offers a variety of traditional Italian dishes, with a strong focus on pizza. The menu features items such as party-sized pizzas, steak subs, and chicken wings, highlighting a selection that caters to both individual and group dining. The restaurant provides a casual atmosphere suited for families and gatherings, emphasizing a welcoming environment and friendly service. Known for its generous portion sizes and quality ingredients, Central Pizza serves crusts with well-crafted toppings and signature sauces. While it primarily operates as a dine-in and takeout establishment, parking may be limited. This approach positions Central Pizza as a reliable local option for Italian cuisine within the Fort Erie community.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy

Crowd

Groups

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Central Pizza - ON L2A 3S5 before visiting.

Reviews for Central Pizza - ON L2A 3S5

4.2

228 reviews

100%

27%

16%

Review highlights

Based on 228 reviews

Central Pizza in Fort Erie consistently receives praise for its generous portion sizes and high-quality Italian offerings, particularly their pizzas and wings. Reviewers often highlight the fresh, flavorful toppings and well-crafted crusts that contribute to a satisfying dining experience. The restaurant’s friendly and attentive staff enhance the welcoming atmosphere, making it a popular choice for group gatherings and celebrations. While the menu is largely focused on pizza and wings, the steak sub also garners positive mentions. Some feedback suggests the addition of more casual, quick-lunch options could further appeal to walk-in customers. Limited parking is a noted minor inconvenience but does not detract significantly from the overall appeal. Overall, Central Pizza is recognized as a dependable destination for quality Italian food with a warm and inviting service environment.

Nicole Burns

Jul 15, 2025

The party sized pizzas are massive, perfect for birthday parties! Friendly service and consistent quality. Nicole -Fort Erie Home Group

Sai Anusha Allaparthi

Jul 13, 2025

We ordered small mushroom pizza. Pizza was so so good. The best Italian pizza i ate. The pizza quantity doesn’t look small it’s like medium size, it serves more than 2 people. I am shocked, what... this is small...? Must try pizza spot in fort erie.

Mathew Ewings

Jul 04, 2025

The pizza has always been excellent from Central. It's our go-to spot for pizza in town. The toppings are high-quality, crust is amazing, and the staff have always been friendly. The chicken wings are very good too. I've never tried any other menu items outside of pizza and wings, so I can't comment on them. But we haven't been disappointed yet. Parking is a bit limited.

E R

Jun 15, 2025

Awesome pizza and wings! Their steak sub is the best!! The sauce they use on their pizza is great! We order the tray pizza most times and everyone loves it!

Jordon Graville

Jun 13, 2025

Amazing staff and everything I've had here so far has been absolutely amazing. Would absolutely benefit from some lunch / walk in options ( like a slice of pizza and pop for 5 or something ) but genuinely great spot for food.

Wes Atkinson

May 17, 2025

I’ve been eating at Central since I was a kid—every visit is a tasty trip down memory lane. The pizza and wings still hit the spot, and the prices are just as friendly as I remember.

Daniel Turner (Dansaturner)

Apr 18, 2025

I had the Spicy Chicken Sandwich with blue cheese, and it was so good that I didn't have a chance to take a picture of it before I ate it!. Well worth the drive over. Will for sure be back again soon. Thank you good sir!

Aaron Look

Apr 17, 2025

Awesome pizza - well loaded with quality toppings. Friendly staff and priced very reasonably. I will be back forsure.